Archive for the ‘Looking for staff’ Category

Too many recruiters are buzzword-matching paper-pushers

Submitted by Tom Sorensen on Tuesday, January 17th, 2012 - 6:42 am

Did you know that most people are not looking for a job? A recent survey made by the US company, The Adler Group conducted together with LinkedIn, revealed that 83% of 4,550 people who participated in the survey, classified themselves as passive candidates. And here is the irony, that HR departments (corporate recruiters) still spend most of their time trying to attract candidates from the remaining 17% and what we call the pool of active candidates.

This recent Adler/LinkedIn survey just confirms what we have known all along. No surprises really and the result is similar to one made by the US Bureau of Labor Statistics some years ago. The bureau said:

“Active candidates are a small group of the total workforce. At any point in time, just only 16% of all employees are actively looking for job. Active candidates are proportionately only a small population of the best talent. The high performers are almost always employed and seldom look for a job”.

Here is Tom’s Law on this subject (learned through 25 years of recruiting people):

“You cannot source and hire passive candidates who are not looking for a new job, in the same way you source and hire active candidates who are.”

There are a large number of recruitment companies (of course none of the recruitment companies who also read this blog, because they know better now) who pull resumes from JobsDB and other job boards and email them over to their clients… without even calling to qualify them first. You see, the process used to find and recruit passive candidates is fundamentally different than the one used for active candidates.

But fair enough if you say that some recruiters do call these candidates to screen for qualifications, but I challenge that they still do not go wide and deep enough for their clients. If you pay a fee of 25% of the successful candidate’s annual income – or a smaller percentage – and you paid only on hiring a candidate presented by your recruitment partner, you are in danger of being taken to the cleaners. I’m going to be very blunt now, but sorry to say that you must blame yourself.

Having said that, executive search firms (including Grant Thornton) have done a lousy job of educating the market and their clients about what you as a client really get for your money. Many companies still believe that you call recruitment companies to buy resumes from their database. And they believe a recruitment company is a recruitment company is a recruitment company. I tell you, nothing could be farther from the truth.

What really annoys me is the predominantly database recruiters who market themselves as headhunters, when what they do is simply shopping for resumes on the internet job boards.  Resume shoppers and buzzword-matching paper-pushers would be a more appropriate designation, don’t you think?

When you engage a recruitment company for less than 25% fee and which is paid only if you hire a candidate, then all that happens is a search or shopping for resumes on the recruiter’s database. They may call two or three people they know in their network to check if they are looking for a new job, but that’s about it. If you are not satisfied with the resumes you receive, they have no where else to go for more resumes since they have exhausted their sources. Rather than telling you this, they will pretend to search for more whilst they take the next caller, hoping to turn around an inquiry quick enough before another contingency recruiters presents someone the client likes.

Think about it. If you only make money by presenting candidates who get hired by a client, and before such client may accept candidates from a competitor, it’s really a matter of throwing spaghetti at the wall to see what sticks. It’s obvious that you get no contingency recruiting team to spend months after months on your search. The risk of working for a long time on a job, and then end up not being paid because you hired from somewhere else, is too high to make it a viable business model.

So by all means try out the cheaper option of contingency recruitment, but keep in mind that if no decent resumes are coming forward, don’t waste your time but move on to other recruitment alternatives. Or risk waiting for a miracle which could be that a relevant candidate happens to send your recruiter a resume one day; but when and do you have the time to wait?

 

 

 

 

Share

Silly quotes from real resumes

Submitted by Tom Sorensen on Tuesday, December 6th, 2011 - 9:59 am

What better way to end a tough year than with some quotes from candidate resumes. I was inspired by a list that I recently saw in Thailand Construction News.  These lines were picked from real resumes and cover letters:

  1. Marital status: often. Children: various.
  2. Reason for leaving last job: They insisted that all employees get to work by 8:45 a.m. every morning. I could not work under those conditions.
  3. The company made me a scapegoat, just like my three previous employers.
  4. Finished eighth in my class of ten.
  5. References: None. I’ve left a path of destruction behind me.
  6. I have lurnt Word Perfect 6.0 computor and spreadsheet progroms.
  7. Reason for leaving last job: maturity leave.
  8. Its best for employers that I not work with people.
  9. Lets meet, so you can ooh and aah over my experience.
  10. You will want me to be Head Honcho in no time.
  11. I was working for my mom until she decided to move.
  12. Marital status: single. Unmarried. Unengaged. Uninvolved. No commitments .
  13. I have an excellent track record, although I am not a horse.
  14. I am loyal to my employer at all costs … Please feel free to respond to my resume on my office voice mail.
  15. I have become completely paranoid, trusting completely no one and absolutely nothing.
  16. My goal is to be a meteorologist. But since I possess no training in meterology, I suppose I should try stock brokerage.
  17. As indicted, I have over five years of analyzing investments.
  18. Personal interests: donating blood. Fourteen gallons so far.
  19. Instrumental in ruining entire operation for a well known chain store.
  20. Note: Please don’t miscontrue my 14 jobs as job-hopping. I have never quit a job.

May I wish all my readers a Happy New Year and my best wishes for a successful 2012. Looking forward to catching up with you soon again.

Share

A cat has nine lives – what about recruitment companies?

Submitted by Tom Sorensen on Wednesday, June 1st, 2011 - 1:14 pm

It’s amazing what some recruitment companies get away with. What I also find amazing is how naive some clients are. Naive because they believe they can get the same amount of work done on their assignment when they pay less to the recruitment company than to the executive search firm.

I say keep dreaming. It’s like in any other business; you get what you pay for.3483_Chain_padlock_color_web

This article is first and foremost to companies who are using recruitment services or executive search firms to help find and recruit candidates. But even you may be a candidate, please continue reading, this story will reveal the different methods used by the recruitment industry. You owe yourself to know who you deal with.

Here’s how I calculated the “less money” which I mentioned above. Take a compensation of 100,000 Baht per month. If you use an executive search firm with a fee of, say 32%, the invoice will be 416,000 Baht. If the recruitment company is charging you 20%, you pay a fee of 260,000 Baht when you employ their candidate. The difference between the two fees, and the 32 to the 20, is 33 percentage points.

5951_11 film reel silver_lavenderHere’s what you get for your money. The 20% fee:

  • You get a recruiter who quickly works through their candidate data base to find whatever comes close to your required profile. They need to work fast, because only if their candidate is hired by you, will they be able to send you an invoice. They know that you have most likely also contacted another recruitment company, thinking that the second recruiter has completely different candidates in their data base than the first one (which is actually not the case; you see, most active candidates send their resumes to many recruitment companies, thereby greatly overlapping the various data bases).
  • The hit and run methodology means the recruiter will use a few days on the data base or the internet job boards, then throw their spaghetti (read: candidate resumes) on the wall and hope that one sticks.
  • The problem is when no candidates are presented to you within the first week or two. Here’s the secret. The recruiter has in fact already moved on to the next caller in the hope of making a quick sale. It’s the nature of the business when you are paid on successful placements only. The attention span is short. If you have no resumes on your table shortly after you placed the order, be worried because no one is working on your job any longer.

More importantly, what do you get for your money paying 32%:olympic_medal_ribbon_original

  • The headhunter is not in a hurry per se. Executive search firms will appoint a consultant and a researcher to work as a team over many weeks or months. They will have spend considerable time in getting to you know your needs and your corporate culture. They will have analysed what are the key competencies, they will have drafted the chart for your approval, prepared a recruitment plan including the targettted firms where they will go hunting. For them it’s not providing a quick fix but a thorough planned approach to ensure that you get exactly the right person.
  • Executive search firms work on exclusive basis and will not take your order unless you commit to them 100%. During the search process they will contact hundreds of candidates to present your company, the job opportunities, and your employee value proposition. They will be hunting passive candidates and not those who are actively looking for a new job because they hate what they are doing or are between jobs.
  • The headhunters will use a script when they call up. They will use a tested best practice approach that will get passive candidates to listen, to think and confirm their interest in moving forward. From the first contact and through to the face-to-face interview, it is all following a well executed path.
  • Real executive search firms do not use internet job boards or printed media advertising. Only active candidates who are job hunting will be looking there anyway. All the passive candidates, who are not looking for job, will not open the job boards or the job classified. So you will only reach these people by calling them (according to US Bureau of Labor Statistics 16% of employees are actively looking; leaving 84% un-reachable).8448_Pot of Gold_coins_web

It’s my prediction that if recruitment companies only provide and sell data base resumes, and no other value added service, they will quickly use up their nine lives. Curiosity killed the cat, right?

Share

What is your Employee Value Proposition

Submitted by Tom Sorensen on Wednesday, August 4th, 2010 - 9:22 am

It’s the same the world over. Within the next 10 to 20 years there will be more people leaving the labour market than joining. From the forecast by United Nations, Thailand will face this dilemma in 2025, only 15 years from now. In fact, though Thailand still enjoys a positive net growth (more people entering than leaving the job market), the decline has already started years ago. I’m afraid it’s going only one way: down and down. The stats also predict that South Korea is due for a contraction in 2015 and Indonesia by 2035.

2770_alarm_clock_purple

But first on the line is China. Already in 6 years, 2016, China will experience a negative net growth in working age population (15-64) entering the job market. Singapore is right behind and the contraction in working age population begins 2017, a decline that started in Singapore only last year.

With the prospect of fewer young Thai people in the labour market it means an increasing aging population. That in turn means a shortage of workers who can support a growing number of retirees. We all know how that will affect economic productivity and also strain the social security and pension systems. Forecasters predict that in Japan the labor force will decrease from 68 million down to 46 million, Italy’s from 23 to 14 million and in Germany the labor market goes from 41 million to 28 million by 2050. Interestingly when looking at figures for Japan, their contraction has been real for the last 16 years. You can only speculate how much this demographic is linked to the economic troubles seen in Japan for many years.

54_no_entry_red

Stop here for a moment – but don’t shoot the messenger now. If you think the war for talent is already in your face everyday, you ain’t seen nothing yet. It’s time ladies and gentlemen to act smarter than the other company on the other side of the street. Introducing the Employee Value Proposition!

Apple, Google, Starbucks and another 50 global brands might not find it very difficult to attract and convince candidates to join their organizations. They have such strong name recognition that it’s more seller’s market than buyer’s market. But the rest of us do not have that luxury of such high public visibility.

Your marketing efforts should no longer be focused on your customers and clients, but more so on your potential employees. You must define your Employee Value Proposition (EVP). It must clearly describe real needs and clarify job expectations. Here are some questions that will help you on the way. They must be answered before you start any sourcing of new staff.

1179_athlete_winning_black

And let me warn you, it will take you the same amount of time, energy, and analysis to make your EVP that you put into your annual business plan and budget. There is no way you can develop the EVP between coffee breaks.

  • Why would someone who is good at this type of work want this particular job?
  • Why should anyone come and work for you?
  • What does this job offer that is unique or makes it most attractive to a potential candidate?
  • Why is doing this job at your company better than doing the same job at a competitor?
  • Why do people come to work at your company and why do they stay? Is it leading edge technology? Fast growth? Industry reputation? Work/life balance? How does it differentiate you from your primary competitors?
  • What is your competitive compensation and benefits plan? 12 or 13 months guaranteed pay, sign-on bonus, performance incentive, company car, medical cover, provident fund, for employee or for family too? Flex time, free parking at the office building?

You must take into consideration what we call Generations at Work. Are you typically employing new staff below 30 years of age? That’s Generation Y and these youngsters have a mind of their own. They may come to work in Steve Madden platform shoes or flip flops, listen to the iPod while working, they want instant gratification and become MD and millionaire before the age of 31. The Employee Value Proposition must reflect the core group you target as your next employees. Babyboomers and even Gen X are different than the Y’s. Waiting in the corridor we even have Gen I (for Internet). You can never rest.

2539_ipod_charcoal_silver

Once you have the EVP in place you can move to describing the 2 – 3 major work challenges to be faced by the candidate in the position? You must define 6 – 8 deliverables i.e. steps required for on-the-job success. In other words, what must the person in this job need to do to be considered extremely successful in this job? Done properly you will have a list of six to eight things the person needs to do over the course of a year that defines great on-the-job performance. Your answer should not describe personal attributes like skills, experience, education or traits.

Remember that applicants or candidates are a perishable commodity. It is the only “product” I know that can speak. They can say no to being “sold” to your organization. The better ones are quickly turned off by unresponsiveness which is interpreted as a lack of initiative or seriousness. Resumes may look like a pile of paperwork on your desk but they really are not. If you don’t act with a sense of urgency and are prepared with an intelligent EVP when meeting future employees the contraction in the labour force will hit you hard and before your competitor.1470_equal_red

Share

Is it better working with 4 recruitment companies at the same time?

Submitted by Tom Sorensen on Tuesday, May 4th, 2010 - 9:58 am

Do you believe you are increasing the likelihood of filling a vacant position by 300 to 400 percent if working with several recruitmen companies? You may think that the recruitment companies all have different data bases containing different resumes, they press the magic button of candidate resumes and shortly after an invoice goes out to their client. Nothing could be further from the truth.2532_group_business_people_black

Now let me tell you what really happens… in the real world of recruitment and executive search. When you ask the first executive recruitment representative, he probably knows about 3 guys off the top of his head that may match what you are looking for. His team at the office will do a quick search and may find another 4 guys. They make 7 phone calls and get this outcome: three guys have already taken other jobs; two are not interested in moving to your company or location; and one or two are just not qualified. End of the day, the recruitment company might get one or two candidates to present. Or maybe none at all.

So you move on and call a second recruit company. They too go through 7 people mentally and through their computer data base. Here’s the dirty little secret. The 5 of the 7 guys are all on the recruitment companies’ lists. You see, active candidates who are actively or semi-actively looking for a new opportuniy have distributed their resumes to perhaps 5 to 10 data base recruitment coompanies (not surprisingly when you think about it). But for you and your company, it means you are not getting exposed to 4 recruitment companies x 7-10 candidates – but probably only to 10 different individuals.

Working with any executive search frim, such as Grant Thornton, I will have my team of researchers talking to over 100 diffrent people. Yes, 100 different people. We will expose your company and vacant position to more than 100 candidates. As a matter of fact, before you even see the first candidate, we will have invested 642,320 Baht in expenses on this search process (a consultant costing model based on average research and interview time).

So it’s your choice… do you want the exposure to 10 – 15 people or work with a process that is going to expose you to over 100 people? Choosing the latter, it will go a long way to ensure that when you make a hiring decision, at least at that moment in time, you have hired the best available person on the market.2078_torch_black

Share

Recruitment is an expensive exercise

Submitted by Tom Sorensen on Tuesday, March 2nd, 2010 - 10:46 am

1241_target_redIf you continuously hire people while losing talent internally your organisation will not survive. Focusing on the internal development of employees is important and it provides a continuous pipeline of fresh talent for leadership positions. An organisation that looks after its staff will reap the benefits and the Grant Thornton International Business Report shows that the private sector is indeed focused on the development of their talent.

Your company brand is not only the image of the business in the minds of your workforce, but also in the minds of any external stakeholders such as potential employees and your clients. Strong employer brands tend to be associated with large multinational organisations. What about your company? Can you clearly articulate the employer brand to attract and importantly retain talent?

If you are not able to convince potential new employees,
who have come to meet you regarding a job opportunity,
that your grass is greener than where they currently are,
it is not likely that they will consider your offer.

As the global market for talent tightens, you must ensure that you have systems in place for finding and identifying the right talent. I have yet to meet any executive in Thailand that finds it easy to identify and hire really talented people. We have clients who go on and on for months in their attempt to find just one that comes  close to the job requirements. They are waiting for a miracle. Waiting to find the needle in the haystack. Meanwhile they are loosing sales opportunities, they are not getting the best deal from their suppliers, existing staff put in extra hours to cover. This is obviously not a healthy situation for very long.

Yet, the fight for talent is only going to get more difficult. Further Grant Thornton research found
that the lack of availability of skills is the biggest constraint on expanding the business.

To recruit and retain the right people you must have in place a human resources structure aligned to the needs of your business. You need to create an environment that not only attracts good people but retains them. It’s about how you treat people, providing the necessary tools and resources, opportunities to learn and access to knowledge. Leadership and management must be inspiring, but also real, consistent and believable. It must all be underpinned with strong values communicated through the day to day experiences the people have of the organisation.

1823_trees_shapes_oliveSo what action do you need to take? First, you must recognise the issues and challenges surrounding talent, both locally and globally. Talent is not restricted by borders. Organisations in every part of the world must identify a sound recruitment and retention strategy.

Secondly, you must focus on human resources solutions. You need to create an employer brand that delivers and communicates strong and consistent messages. Values need to be defined and embedded not just in words but in very action you take. Internal talent development is as important as recruitment of new talent into an organisation. You need defined competency frameworks so you recruit not just any talent but the right talent.

Finally, take action. Recruitment and retention needs to be at the centre of management decision. HR is a strategic function and should be represented at the highest level of your organisation, no matter what the size, nature or level of maturity.

Share

Career in Executive Search?

Submitted by Tom Sorensen on Thursday, October 1st, 2009 - 8:31 am

I’m hiring Associate Consultants and Research Associates

Career in Executive Search?

To be successful you must have courage to cold-call people; the telephone must be your best friend;  attracting both active and passive candidates, you will screen and select suitable candidates to put forward to client companies.

Required Qualifications:

  • Thai national over 30 years of age.
  • Passion for selling job opportunities over the phone.2531_group_business_people_colour
  • Good interpersonal and communications skills.
  • Keen to learn and enjoy responsibility.
  • Excellent command of English.
  • Ambitious and confident.
  • Courteous and friendly.

Come and join one of the most successful and respected executive search firms in Thailand.

We select recruitment consultants on their ability to contact executives and managerial candidates by telephone; talking to people you have never met or talked to before. You must be able to sell opportunities and inspire candidates. We do not sell resumes – we deliver candidates. We do not shop on the internet job boards – we hunt people.

Great recruiters make it happen through hard work, making the right calls, build relationships, interact with candidates, understand the opportunity gap in a candidate’s current situation, determine the decision-making criteria a candidate will use to make a change, work with a candidate to help them land a better opportunity, and navigate the delicate offer, negotiation, counteroffer, and notice-giving minefield. End of it all you impress the clients by presenting equally top qualified candidates within a short time. All that’s just a highlight the things great recruiters do well.

Our recruitment procedures are well documented and guide our professional business process. We are a learning organization that emphasizes continuous training of our consultants. We only want the best. Are you one of them?

To prove you have courage and good telephone skills…  please call Khun Nannapat or
Khun Tom:

  • Nannapat 02 205 82441045_telephone_charcoal
  • Tom 02 205 8240.

We can always get your resume later.

Share

Does your company use a licensed recruiter?

Submitted by Tom Sorensen on Thursday, October 1st, 2009 - 8:21 am

Have you ever checked if your preferred supplier of recruitment services is licensed by the Ministry of Labour? Or is operating a business which is illegal and not complying with the law? Here is why you should know.

The law in Thailand that regulates recruitment companies is called “The Recruitment and Job Seeker Protection Act”. It regulates all types of recruitment companies, from brokers sending Thais overseas to database agencies to executive search firms.

Be aware of un-lincensed recruitment companies

The very first and original Employment Act was enacted over 40 years ago, back in B.E. 2511 (1968), and was used for enforcement of overseas employment service businesses. Due to an increase in incidents where Thais were left in trouble overseas, often without passports and money that were held by unscrupulous brokers, the old law was amended to become the Employment and Job Seeker Protection Act B.E. 2528 (1985). Amendments have been made several times since then, latest in B.E. 2544 (2001).

The purpose of the Act is to provide job seekers good protection when recruitment service providers are involved in the search and hiring process. The Department of Employment under the Ministry of Labour is in charge and controls the execution of this Act.

My own personal recruitment license is KT130/2552.

Companies who wish to offer employment and recruitment services in Thailand must register with the Ministry of Labor and will in turn receive a license to operate once the office has been approved that it complies with the ministry regulations. Names of all staff working in a recruitment company must register with the Ministry of Labor by submitting an application, photo and a clean criminal record from the police. In addition any staff with client contact must also hold a special Identity Card.

The juristic person of a local recruitment and employment service provider must be a Thai national, and the company must deposit 100,000 Baht as a financial guarantee with the Registrar Officer.  An overseas employment service provider must be a company limited or a public company having fully paid registered capital of not less than Baht 1 million and a financial guarantee of Baht 5 million deposited with the Central Employment Registrar Officer.

Recruitment companies are required to submit a monthly report of activities to the Ministry of Labor as well as keep on site several other reports that can be inspected by the Ministry of Labor.

Next time you call a recruitment company make sure you ask if they are in compliance with the law. Grant Thornton’s Executive Recruitment holds a proper license from the Ministry of Labour.

Share

Time Kills All Deals

Submitted by Tom Sorensen on Tuesday, September 1st, 2009 - 8:03 am

Headhunters – executive search firms – are the extended arm of your company and are your best connection to the outside world when it comes to finding top candidates. Headhunters are not magicians though and cannot present relevant candidates from one day to the other.

By definition their assignments are difficult-to-fill positions, but keep in mind that this is where headhunters excel. They have the capability of finding talented candidates and put them in front of you. It is going to be up to you to attract them to your firm. These candidates will typically be accomplishers, currently employed, with good futures where they are.259_carrier_bag_orange

Candidates are a perishable commodity. It is the only product I know that can speak. They can say no to being “sold” to a client. The better ones are quickly turned off by unresponsiveness which is interpreted as a lack of initiative or seriousness on behalf of the hiring company. Resumes may look like a pile of paperwork on your desk but they really are not. Each resume is a real person that has been cultivated, screened, and convinced to meet with your company.

Share